LinkedIn
← All Insights
AnalysisPolicy & Funding WatchMaritimeEconomic DevelopmentTax Credits

Regional Bids for Maritime Prosperity Zones Miss the Boat

Ten regions are lining up for 100 Maritime Prosperity Zone census tracts in a program Congress hasn't created yet. The fight that decides who wins isn't between them — it's over the certification standard neither House bill contains.

Regional Bids for Maritime Prosperity Zones Miss the Boat — Prosody Consulting case study

Maryland Gov. Wes Moore signed an executive order on October 21 standing up a Maryland Maritime Task Force. Its first listed duty is to “take all actions necessary to secure a Maritime Prosperity Zone designation for the State.” Maryland is now the sixth region to put something public on the table in pursuit of a Maritime Prosperity Zone (MPZ), and the first to do it with a governor’s signature and a reporting deadline. The instinct is understandable: there are only 100 designations on offer. But the regions are fighting in the wrong theater, over a program that doesn’t exist yet, and the fight that actually decides who wins is going almost uncontested.

Key takeaways

  • There is no program yet. No tract has been designated, and no official has authority to designate one. Neither House bill (H.R. 9911 or H.R. 3151) has moved out of the Ways and Means Committee since July 23. Maryland’s own announcement concedes the designation comes “once Congress acts to create the program.”
  • The cap is 100 census tracts, not 100 ports. Every text on the table, including the White House’s EC-4437 draft, caps population census tracts. Depending on how they are drawn and bundled, that could be a dozen real industrial complexes or sixty.
  • Neither bill says how tracts get chosen. The House bills carry no certification standard and no regional distribution requirement. The White House draft has both. Nobody is carrying them.
  • Inland rivers and the Great Lakes are already in. Both bills qualify tracts by NAICS code, and inland water freight, Great Lakes freight, and water-transport support activities are on the list.
  • The decisive fight is over the standard. Whoever shapes the certification language decides who gets the 100 tracts. That happens in Ways and Means, before any region gets a designation.

Who’s already in line

Six regions have put something in writing:

  • Southeast Michigan — a coalition led by the University of Michigan and Macomb Community College, with the Detroit/Wayne County Port Authority at the core and 30-plus supporting organizations across four counties.
  • The California Delta — a January proposal from the owners of Mare Island on behalf of a six-organization coalition.
  • Southeast Alaska — matching joint resolutions from Wrangell, Ketchikan and the Ketchikan Gateway Borough nominating a Southeast Alaska Maritime Industrial Corridor.
  • Maryland — by executive order, with an initial assessment due February 1, 2027 and an action plan due April 1.
  • St. Louis — an op-ed from four port directors in two states, with no resolution or boundary behind it.
  • Tampa Bay — a single clause in an EDC progress update recommending MPZs to the State of Florida.

Planning commentary in Hampton Roads adds Philadelphia, the Texas Gulf Coast, the Upper Mississippi and Hampton Roads itself. Call it ten geographies, chasing 100 tracts, in a program Congress hasn’t created. Picture a band in full stage gear lost in the corridors under the arena, shouting “Hello, Cleveland!” They’re in the right city. They just haven’t found the stage, because nobody has built it yet.

The arithmetic most people get wrong

Coverage routinely describes the cap as 100 zones, 100 facilities, or 100 regions. It is 100 census tracts. A tract holds roughly 4,000 people and is drawn for statistical convenience, not maritime commerce. On a dense urban waterfront one tract might hold a terminal, a shipyard and three suppliers. On a river corridor a tract can run for miles of farm ground and catch one grain elevator at its edge.

That cuts two ways. The scarcity is real, so a single port authority reading the cap has every reason to get in line early. But the House bills set only how many tracts, not which ones, how they’re grouped, or how they’re spread across the country. The White House’s EC-4437 draft did answer that, requiring representation across seven regions: the East Coast, West Coast, Great Lakes, Gulf, Alaska, inland rivers, and noncontiguous states and territories. H.R. 9911, introduced six weeks later, doesn’t carry it.

The instruments point toward systems, not slices

The federal direction on where these zones should go is consistent. Executive Order 14269 (April 2025) directs Commerce to propose zones that are “geographically diverse, including river regions as well as the Great Lakes.” America’s Maritime Action Plan (February 2026) extends that to Alaska, Hawaii and the territories. Neither designates anything, but both tell Commerce where the administration wants these zones.

The bills follow. H.R. 9911 qualifies tracts by industry code, and 483211 (inland water freight), 483113 (coastal and Great Lakes freight) and 4883 (support activities for water transportation) are on the list. H.R. 3151’s shorter list carries the same three. Inland and Great Lakes geographies don’t have to argue their way into eligibility.

What’s missing is the standard. H.R. 9911 simply says the Secretary “certifies such nomination and designates such tract.” H.R. 3151 asks the Maritime Administrator only whether a tract contains or is a viable site for a shipyard, port or harbor facility. The White House draft goes further, directing Treasury to certify within 30 days every nominated tract that contains or is a viable site for a shipyard, port, harbor facility, maritime supplier, vessel module construction or maritime workforce training. That workable standard has existed since June. Nobody has picked it up.

There’s precedent for treating a river system as one geography. Federal law already does it: 46 U.S.C. 51706 limits MARAD’s Centers of Excellence for maritime workforce training to schools in states bordering, among others, “the Mississippi River System.”

The argument is already on the record

In December 2025, eight Great Lakes senators, four from each party, asked the President to establish MPZs using “an industry reference rather than geography,” an approach that “assures a common application of prosperity zones across the Great Lakes without winners and losers based on geographic location.” Trade columnist Craig Hooper argued in 2025 that “mariners — not economists — should be identifying maritime prosperity zones.” A June 2026 University of Michigan study for the Great Lakes St. Lawrence Governors and Premiers recommended multi-state, region-wide designations.

And one bid already asked the right way. The St. Louis op-ed, signed by port directors from Missouri and Illinois, didn’t ask for a St. Louis designation. It asked for “strategic designation of inland Maritime Prosperity Zones” as a category. It’s the only ask in the field that gets stronger when someone else makes it too.

What it means for you

If you’re a port authority, economic developer, shipyard or maritime supplier weighing an MPZ play:

  • Get the cap right in your own materials. It’s 100 census tracts. Describing it as 100 ports makes the fight look more winnable than it is.
  • Put your energy into the standard, not the slice. Ask your member of Congress to support a certification standard in H.R. 9911 that designates at corridor scale and lets tracts be bundled where an industrial footprint crosses tract lines. The White House’s EC-4437 draft is a workable starting point. Members on Ways and Means matter most.
  • Coordinate with your neighbors. A system-level ask from a river corridor or a Great Lakes bloc is stronger than ten competing tract-level asks. The MPZ Coalition, founded by Prosody’s Charles R. “Bob” Brettell, exists to put those regions in one room. Membership is free.
  • Watch the clock. H.R. 9911 would take effect after December 31, 2026 and gives Commerce until July 1, 2027 to begin nominations. Maryland’s written case is due February 1. Michigan’s own strategy commits to a first Michigan MPZ by the end of 2026, with no apparatus yet behind it.

The window to shape the standard closes as soon as a committee print or rulemaking fills it. After that, the scramble for slices is all that’s left.

Prosody reads maritime policy the way our clients need it — translated into what it means for a specific port, corridor, or project. This is policy and market intelligence, not legal advice. Talk to us about your project →

Let's talk

Want to talk about something like this?

Tell us what you're working on. Within two business days you'll have our read — what we'd do, and whether we're the right firm to do it.

Free resource

Download

Tell us where to send it. We'll deliver the brief right away and keep you posted when there's something new worth reading.